A tree owner has a responsibility, known in law as ‘the duty of care’, that is to avoid acts or omissions which a reasonable person is likely to foresee may result in harm or injury. In other words, the tree owner should not follow a course of action, or fail to follow a course of action that may result in damage to property or injury to people. The key words with regard to responsibility are; reasonable, likely and foreseeable.
Nuisance
When a tree growing on land owned by ‘A’ is indirectly interfering with the ‘use or enjoyment’ of land owned by ‘B’, for example by encroaching roots or branches, this known in law as nuisance.
Where nuisance occurs, B has the right to remove the roots or branches. This is known as abating a nuisance. Note that any roots or branches (including any fruit) removed must be returned to the owner of the tree.
However, it is important to remember that the occupier of plot B also has a duty of care towards the owner of plot A. Owner B must not exercise their right of abatement in such a way as to cause harm to the tree owned by A, for example by causing a tree to become unstable.
Trespass
When a tree growing on land owned by A is directly interfering with the ‘use or enjoyment’ of land the owned by B, for example by causing direct (through physical contact) or indirect damage (subsidence), this is known in law as trespass. It may be possible for the affected landowner to seek financial compensation from the tree owner, alternatively, owner B may seek an injunction to have the offending tree pruned or possibly removed.
Poisonous Trees
Where a tree (such as yew) is poisonous to animals or (less commonly) to humans, the tree owner must ensure that its branches are not allowed to grow over neighbouring land where any poisonous parts may be eaten. Pruned branches or clippings must not be left where they could be eaten.
Conflict Resolution
The ideal way to resolve a dispute is to discuss the matter, between the interested parties, in a friendly manner in the hope that an amicable settlement can be reached. If that fails, an alternative may be for the parties to appoint an arbitrator to make an impartial decision. If an agreement still cannot be reached either party may ask the Courts to make a ruling. This can be a lengthy and expensive procedure and should only be considered as a final resort and after taking legal advice.
Note: For specific advice, with respect to the law, please seek qualified legal opinion.
Reference: Veteran Trees: A Guide to Risk and Responsibility published by English Nature Hazards from Trees published by The Forestry Commission
