An Introduction to Visual Amenity Valuation of Trees and Woodlands

Introduction

 The Helliwell System is one of several methods of placing a monetary value on the visual amenity provided by individual trees and/or woodland.

It has been extensively used in court cases, insurance claims and public inquiries to place visual amenity values on individual trees and is supported by the Tree Council and the Arboricultural Association.

The Helliwell System

The Helliwell system was originally devised as a means of achieving logical decisions in the planning and management of woodlands and urban tree populations, by assessing the relative contribution of different trees and woodlands to the visual quality of the landscape. It is inevitable that some of the factors involved are rather subjective, as people’s perceptions of visual amenity are subjective. This can result in different user’s arriving at different values; but it is usually possible for such differences to be resolved, either by the users themselves or by an independent arbitrator.

Monetary Value

 There is no simple straightforward method of attaching a monetary value to visual amenity.

The Helliwell system enables an assessor to ascribe a visual amenity value to a tree or woodland on a points scale. This figure can then be multiplied by a conversion factor, to arrive at an appropriate monetary value for planning purposes. The important features of the method are:

  1. the system used to arrive at a points value must be soundly based,
  2. the intervals on the scale must have similar values,
  3. the monetary conversion factor must be realistic, and must be accepted as such by a wide spectrum of users, in addition to being clearly independent of any particular

From 1st January 2019 a conversion factor of £37.70 is awarded for each point.

Evaluation Method

Six factors are identified for each tree. Special factors such as historical association or exceptional rarity, which are not purely visual, were also taken into account originally. However, it is now considered that these did not fit readily into the basic system, and could also be misapplied, so they are no longer included. Other ‘special’ factors such as the screening of unpleasant views or the importance of a tree within a larger composition should be assessed within the six basic factors.

For each of these factors the tree is given a score, and the scores for all six factors are then multiplied together. The multiplication of the scores is a necessary procedure where factors are inter ­ related but act independently, as is this case. A tree which is large, long- lived, prominent, and suitable for its setting will have a high score. If, on the other hand, a tree is very small, so defective as to have little further useful life expectancy, or is totally unsuited to its setting, it will score little or nothing under the relevant heading and when the scores are multiplied together the tree will have little or no overall score, even if it has scored highly on some other factors. An additive system would not achieve this result.

The product of the scores is then be multiplied by the current monetary conversion factor to arrive at an assessment of the visual amenity value of the tree in monetary terms.

 

 

Factor

Points Available
0 0.5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
i) Size (m2) <2 2 – 5 5 -10 10 –

20

20 – 30 30 – 50 50 –

100

100 –

150

150 –

200

over 200
ii) Duration (years) <2 – 2-5 4-40 40-100 100+
iii) Importance None Very little Little Some Considerable Great
iv) Tree Cover Woodland Many Some Few None
v) Suitability Not Poor Just Fairly Very Particularly
vi) Form – Poor Average Good – –

Visual amenity valuation table showing factors and scores available for individual trees

The Factors

1. Size of tree

The size of the tree is assessed as an area of the tree when viewed from the side. It is calculated as the height of the tree multiplied by the average crown diameter e.g. a tree 15.0m in height with an average crown diameter of 4.0m has a calculated area of 60.0m2.

2. Expected duration of visual amenity

An estimate of the probable length of time that the tree is likely to contribute to the visual amenity of its location. This will take into account the normal biological life span of a tree of that species, its current approximate age and any other factors which may either extend or to reduce the safe useful life expectancy, including the trees position and structural condition.

3. Importance of position in the landscape

This factor is an expression of the visual prominence of the tree. A single prominent tree in a city centre will rate highly under this factor, while an individual tree a secluded residential area will not.

4. Presence of other trees

This factor considers the general abundance of trees within the locality or ‘visual area’. The loss of one tree in an area of abundance may be less important, other thing being equal, than the loss of a similar tree in an area with few other trees.

5. Relation to setting

This factor is very difficult to determine. A small tree in a large space may appear insignificant and score lowly. Equally a large tree in a small space may appear overwhelming or inappropriate and also score lowly. Trees which screen an unpleasant view may be given a higher score; equally a weeping willow hanging down into flowing water or a cedar of Lebanon in the grounds of a country estate may attract a higher score.

6. Form

Most trees will be rated average. Form is entirely rated in terms of aesthetics and beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Please Note:

The valuation of trees for amenity purposes can never be a totally precise exercise, and derived monetary value should be regarded as guide rather than a precision instrument.