Trees, Roots and Existing Structures

Introduction

There are two types of damage which trees may cause to existing structures, namely direct and indirect.

Direct Damage

 Direct damage occurs as a result of the pressure exerted by either the trunk of the tree or by the primary structural roots, and is usually confined to the ‘zone of rapid taper’. Trees typically have between 4 and 11 primary structural roots. These roots may be up to 30cm in diameter at the stem base of a mature tree but they taper very rapidly, so that at a distance of 2.0 to 3.0m from the base of the tree they are usually only 2 to 5cm in diameter (zone of rapid taper), by which stage they have lost much of their rigidity and much of their physical strength.

The pressure exerted by either the trunk or the primary structural roots can affect lightly loaded structures such as kerbs, paving, driveways, boundary and retaining walls and but very rarely affects heavily loaded structures such as residential buildings.

Indirect Damage

 Indirect damage or subsidence occurs when tree roots extract moisture from at or below the level of the foundations of a heavily loaded structure; tree related subsidence occurs on shrinkable soils, usually clay (Biddle 1998). If the foundations of the structure are inadequate, this may result in subsidence and cracks appearing in the structure above.

If cracks appear in a structure and it is thought that a tree on the neighbouring land may be to blame then the tree owner (or their insurer) may be liable for the cost of repairs. In order to demonstrate liability, evidence should be provided beyond a reasonable doubt that the tree is in fact responsible. It may also be necessary to demonstrate that the damage was reasonably foreseeable and that the tree owner should have taken action to remove the threat.

It should be noted that there is a normal seasonal drying and wetting of soil and also that a possible consequence of removing a tree is heave, as the moisture previously removed by the tree swells the soil.

In General

Tree roots like branches do not respect boundaries; they are opportunistic and grow wherever the soil conditions are most suitable. Roots crossing a boundary are a nuisance and may be cut back to the boundary in the same way as branches may be cut back to the boundary (be sure to check for Statutory Protection before proceeding). Removing roots may adversely affect the stability of the tree and its ability to take up water and nutrients.

The nearer to the trunk the cutting occurs the greater the risk to the health and safety of the tree (Dobson 1995). A tree owner may have a claim against his neighbour if the tree dies or otherwise fails as a result of such an action, although this has not been tested in Court to date.

Having crossed a boundary roots may enter a defective drain and cause a blockage (Brennan et al 1997); they may grow under and crack driveways and pavements and they may contribute to building subsidence. In such cases a neighbour may seek recompense for the damage caused and a Court Injunction restraining the owner from allowing further root trespass. However, in considering liability, damages may only be awarded if it can be shown that the tree owner was negligent; i.e. the damage was reasonably foreseeable and the tree owner should have taken preventative action.

For specific advice, with respect to the law, please seek qualified legal opinion.

Reference: The above is based on APN 11 Trees and Hedge in Dispute.