Trees, Shrink-Swell and Existing Buildings

Trees, Shrink-Swell & Existing Buildings

A brief introduction

Trees, Shrink-Swell and Existing Buildings

The following is a brief introduction to tree related shrink-swell (often referred to as subsidence and heave) and relates to existing low-rise commercial and domestic buildings.

Introduction

Shrink-swell is the most damaging geohazard in Britain today, costing the economy £540 million following a drought in 1991. Heat waves in 2003 and 2006 led to peaks in shrink-swell claims. More recently, the Association of British Insurers (ABI) reported that over 10,000 households made claims worth a total of £64 million during July to September in 2018 (ABI, 2018). The ABI stated that the 350 per cent increase in the value of claims during July to September 2018 was the highest quarterly jump since records started more than 25 years ago.

TIn the USA, the estimated damage to buildings and infrastructure exceeds $15 billion annually. The American Society of Civil Engineers estimates that one in four homes have some damage caused by shrink–swell soils; in a typical year, such soils cause a greater financial loss to property owners than earthquakes, floods, hurricanes and tornadoes combined (Nelson and Miller, 1992).
British Geological Survey

What is a shrink-swell?

Shrink-swell only occurs where there are geological stability hazards; these geological stability hazards may be natural or man-made.

The six most common ground stability hazards are:

  • collapsible ground,
  • compressible ground,
  • ground dissolution,
  • landslips,
  • running sand, and
  • swelling clay

Mining is an entirely man-made stability hazard

Ground instability refers to the propensity for upward, lateral or downward movement of the ground. Some movements may be gradual and of millimetre or centimetre scale, whilst others may be sudden and of metre or tens of metres scale.

Tree related shrink swell only occurs on swelling clay. Trees do not contribute to shrink swell damage associated with the other five common ground stability hazards.

Shrinkage can cause differential settlement in buildings and structures whilst swelling can cause lifting.

Swelling Clays

Shrink-swell damage occurs on swelling clays, as a result of changes in the moisture content. The changes in moisture content cause a change in volume of the clay resulting in either the ground shrinking or swelling.

Shrinkage can cause differential settlement in buildings and structures whilst swelling can cause lifting of buildings and structures.

Moisture content can and does vary naturally with the seasons and hence clay rich deposits will naturally shrink and swell during the course of the year.

Soil moisture content can be influenced by a wide range of factors, including but not limited to, the presence of trees. This report does not consider the wider range of factors that may influence soil moisture content.

Trees and Shrink-Swell

There are five primary factors to be considered when assessing the likelihood of trees causing or contributing to shrink-swell (subsidence or heave). These factors are:

  • swelling clays – the presence or lack of
  • tree species,
  • tree height,
  • distance of the tree from the building, and
  • depth of foundations

Trees including shrubs and hedgerows extract moisture from the ground and on swelling clays this can cause shrinkage in volume. The extent to which a tree extracts moisture from the ground is determined by the species of the tree and the zone of influence. The zone of influence defines the lateral extent from which a tree extracts moisture. The zone of influence of a tree is determined by the water demand, and the mature height of the tree, please see Table 1 below ‘Water demand of tree species in relation to their height -selected trees’. The zone of influence of a tree is given in table 2 below.

Table 1. Water demand of tree species in relation to their height – selected trees

Water Demand Species Mature Height
High Cypress 20
Hawthorn 10
Oak – English 20
Willow – Weeping 16
Moderate Apple 10
Beech 20
Blackthorn 8
Pine – all 20
Low Birch 14
Hazel 8
Holly 12
Magnolia 9

 

The zone of influence of a tree is determined by the water demand and the mature height of the tree (see table 1).

Table 2. The zone of influence of a tree.

Water Demand Zone of Influence
High 1.25 x mature height
Moderate 0.75 x mature height
Low 0.5 x mature height

 

Examples: An English oak can extract soil moisture at a distance of 25.0m from a building whereas a holly tree can extract soil moisture at a distance of 6.0m from a building.

National House Building Council (NHBC)

The combination of swelling clays and trees, hedgerows or shrubs represents a potential hazard to structures that requires special consideration. Trees, hedgerows, and shrubs take moisture from the ground, and, in swelling clays, this can cause significant volume changes resulting in ground movement. This has the potential to affect foundations and damage the supported structure. In order to minimise this risk, foundations should be designed to accommodate the movement or be taken to a depth where the likelihood of damaging movement is low.

Picture

The NHBC provide guidance for common foundation types to deal with the hazard and includes suitable foundation depths which have been established from field data, research, NHBC data and practical experience. The depths are not those at which root activity, desiccation and ground movement are non-existent, but they are intended to provide an acceptable level of risk. However, if significant quantities of roots are unexpectedly encountered in the base of the trench, the excavation may need to be deepened.

Consideration has been given to the potential effects of climate change in the guidance provided.

Trees, Shrink-Swell and Existing Buildings – a Summary

Trees can cause or contribute to shrink-swell in the presence of swelling clays when the foundations of an existing building are inadequate. Conversely, when the foundations are adequate, regardless of the presence of swelling clays or the presence of trees, the risk of shrink-swell is insignificant.

Buildings, constructed after 1989, are assumed to comply with technical requirements of the National House Building Council, and the risk posed to the supported structure by trees, hedgerows or shrubs is deemed to be acceptable.

References:

National House Building Council Chapter 4.2 Building near trees 2021
British Geological Survey Note Ground shrinking and swelling – May 2012
A British Geological Survey Natural Ground Stability Report – March 2018
A Natural Ground Stability report produced by the British Geological Survey dated December 2023

Picture

Photo 1 (above): Differential subsidence due to the downslope side of house moving on shrinkable deposit. Image: Chris Page.

Picture

Photo 2 (above): Damage to the corner of a house by heave. Image: Peter Kelse

Get in touch today!

Find a balance between green space and the built environment

Very useful information and swiftly supplied in time of need This company was there with out of office hours support to my questions Excellent and thank you once again.

Susan Hoare

What a friendly supporting company. Within 30 minutes of sending an email question a positive reply came back! What more of a recommendation is necessary? Thank you Nick!

Patrick Ward

Nick has given us advice on tree matters at our last two houses and his advice has always been clear, friendly and competent. He has always responded without delay and done what he says he will do

David Holland

Portfolio

Our Projects

The Advice Centre

Learn

Learn to manage your Trees and Landscaping

Visit our advice centre for information regarding trees, root systems and the law.
 
 

Signup to Receive our 'Tree'-Mail Service!

Email Subscribe

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

Click below to subscribe to our Tree-Mail

Latest News, Advice, Industry Research

Our regular email newsletter includes Latest News, Advice, Industry Research and much more. Sign up today to recieve yours.
cas logo color
isa logo color e1561671203276
charted member logo
aa logo